Consumer Group Urges MPUC to Approve the Line 3 Preferred Route

Mother and little son in the car reading

Columbus, OH – At the close of the filing deadline for interested stakeholders to comment on Enbridge’s Line 3 replacement project, Consumer Energy Alliance (CEA) Midwest Executive Director Chris Ventura made the following statement urging the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission to approve the project with Enbridge’s preferred route:

“Without a doubt, the “in-trench replacement” suggested by the ALJ will delay modernizing Minnesota’s energy infrastructure, adding cost, complexity and environmental risk as well as burdening families, farmers, and businesses across the state with increased energy costs.

“With fuel prices currently on the rise, the ALJ’s “in-trench replacement” will add new, and unnecessary constraints to the energy we all rely on daily to take our children to school, go to work, and run our errands. By placing Line 3 out of service for a potential year as the ALJ suggests, we expect fuel shortage and increased prices for families and businesses across the state until the construction is completed.

“Protecting the pocketbooks of families and businesses who cannot afford the burden of higher energy bills as a result of political decisions means modernizing Minnesota’s infrastructure in the safest, most efficient way.  Replacing Line 3 along Enbridge’s preferred route will not only ensure our fuel supply is secure, but that our environment is protected with the least amount of disruptions to Minnesota communities.”

###

About Consumer Energy Alliance
Consumer Energy Alliance (CEA) brings together families, farmers, small businesses, distributors, producers and manufacturers to support America’s energy future. With more than 500,000 members nationwide, our mission is to help ensure stable prices and energy security for households across the country. We believe energy development is something that touches everyone in our nation, and thus it is necessary for all of us to actively engage in the conversation about how we develop our diverse energy resources and energy’s importance to the economy. Learn more at ConsumerEnergyAlliance.org.

Contact:
Emily Haggstrom
P: 720-582-0242
ehaggstrom@consumerenergyalliance.org

Explore Energy Sources Now for Use Later

Offshore wind farm

CEA’s Kevin Doyle combats the myths surrounding offshore energy exploration and production far off Georgia’s coast in the Atlantic so families can benefit from new economic opportunities and lower energy costs.

The federal government continues to examine whether to open waters off the coast of Georgia for energy exploration. Many are under the impression they’ll see oil platforms during their upcoming trips to the beach.

That won’t happen. Platforms or wind towers would be dozens of miles offshore. You wouldn’t run into any jet skiing or parasailing. We’re also a long way from such structures being built.

Read more – Savannah Morning News

Energy Grows Safety

Firefighters in Station

What keeps us safe? Some of us might think that it is a tightly locked home? Some people invest in alarm systems to keep them safe. For others, maybe it’s a large vehicle with all the latest safety features.

What makes one of us feel safe might not matter to another, but more likely, it’s likely a combination of those things (plus many others), but I’d argue its people, and the things they create and monitor, that make us safe.

I’m talking about the men and women in uniform, like our military, police, firefighters, first responders, and even energy employees that help keep us safe.

For example, energy plays two important roles in our military. First, our service men and women are constantly operating tactical equipment, from tanks to aircraft carriers and from masks to parachutes, while running operations and military bases, as well as other sophisticated technologies, which are all focused on keeping them, and us, safe.

This, of course, requires massive amounts of energy to ensure our defense system runs strong 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, 365 days a year — without interruption.  It is estimated that the U.S. Department of Defense employs nearly two million servicemen and women and is the largest single consumer of energy in the world. For example, the Air Force alone uses an estimated 2.5 billion gallons of fuel at a cost of $9 billion per year.

To power that many service men and women around the world requires energy from somewhere, and there are two obvious sources, either domestically from within our own borders, or from imports. Of course, the more energy we can produce here at home means less importing or fighting overseas to gain access to energy. In short, America’s safety, and that of our friends and neighbors depends on reliable energy.

Our military isn’t the only group that keeps us safe, at the local level, it’s our police, firefighters, and first-responders. From their vehicles to their equipment, energy is needed to keep our neighborhoods and inner cities safe.

But did you know that these local services are also funded from taxes on the energy industry? That’s right; tax revenue from local energy production — called a severance tax on mineral resources and property tax for renewable resources — goes to local communities to pay for things like their police and fire departments, as well as the roads they use to get to from point A – B (sometimes, even in an emergency.)

Rules also keep us safe. And to the extent you believe that our government is composed of people – voted for by the people and for the people — then regulations are also meant to keep us safe. Federal, state and local government work together to help ensure energy is developed responsibly. That means energy is produced in a manner that protects our environment, and our people at the same time.

The BP Statistical Review of World Energy, a leading resource on carbon dioxide tracking, revealed that since 2005, annual emissions have declined by 758 million metric tons. That’s the largest decline of any country in the world and is nearly as large as the decline for the entire European Union during that same time. In February this year, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) declared gross greenhouse (GHG) emissions decreased by 2 percent between 2015-2016. Now, GHGs are just 2.6 percent above 1990 levels, 11.6 percent below 2005 levels. Another EPA report even states that “All told, total greenhouse gas emissions are approximately 13% below 2005 levels, or roughly halfway to the U.S.’s abandoned Paris Agreement target of 26% below 2005 levels by 2025.” That means organizations, companies, and people are working hard to meet our climate goals while also considering the benefits energy brings to everything around us, including our safety.

So the next time someone tells you we’re ruining the environment and our safety is in jeopardy, share these facts and let them know we can produce the energy we need while keeping our families safe.

Energy Grows Renewables

Wind turbine with workers

There is a large and growing debate in circles across the country and around the world on whether we should or can move to 100 percent renewables or a zero carbon future. No matter where you lie, industry folks from both side of the coin tend to agree – it’s not that we all wouldn’t like to get there, it’s more like how do we do it?

Employees and supporters of oil and gas don’t claim they are superior fuels just that we use them in most things we make and do. A simple acknowledgment that as we work towards finding solutions for the future that we think about everything that is tied to energy development. Similarly, renewable energy employees and supporters acknowledge that switching to 100 percent renewables now is not possible. The fact remains – both of these industries need each other.

In fact, traditional energy sources can really complement and partner with renewable energy sources to help us continue moving forward to meet our nation’s goal to reduce our emissions while diversifying our country’s energy portfolio.

Traditional and renewable energy may seem like opposites, but that can be a good thing. Our energy mix and how we best utilize all of our natural resources is sort of like putting together a big puzzle. When you first open it there are 1000 tiny pieces. Some are upside down, some are backward – you have to look for the edges and the middle as you start to get organized, but you know, somehow, they will all fit together. And with enough time, patience and strategy, they’ll all eventually fit together perfectly.”

It’s true, our big picture conversations about energy have become politicized and turned into one side vs. the other. Whatever happened to all-of-the-above? Was it a passing fad? It shouldn’t have been – because energy isn’t political.

It turns out renewable energy actually needs traditional energy. That’s right, energy grows energy.

For example, wind and solar can be great energies to harness when the wind is blowing and the sun is shining.  But there isn’t a battery big enough to store its power for nightfall or when the weather turns. Both wind and solar need backup power sources and energy experts at the Massachusetts Institute for Technology (MIT) have pointed to natural gas because of its many flexible attributes. Gas power plants have quick “ramp up” capabilities, which means they can be turned on in a matter of minutes to generate electricity whenever it’s needed.  Because let’s face it, we want the lights to come on regardless of the weather outside or what time of day (or night) it is.

And that could work really well in a state like New Mexico that has both great sun and great wind. The American Wind Energy Association (AWEA) recently touted the $2.9 billion that’s been invested in New Mexico’s wind industry and dubbed it a “rising star” because it’s adding wind power capacity faster than any other state in the country. According to AWEA, wind power, the largest source of U.S. renewable electricity generating capacity, now supplies more than 30 percent of the electricity in four states, Iowa, Kansas, Oklahoma, and South Dakota.

Thankfully New Mexico is ready to back that wind up with a whole lot of natural gas they are already producing right in there in their state. The Permian Basin that straddles the Texas-New Mexico border is BOOMING with oil production, and where you have oil, you also have gas.  Companies are now wondering what to do with all the natural gas their producing. We know! “Hello gas, meet wind.”  This potential partnership could be incredible for New Mexico.

And here’s our favorite bipartisan part.  In a joint statement, New Mexico’s congressional delegation — Democratic Sens. Tom Udall and Martin Heinrich, Republican Rep. Steve Pearce and Democratic Reps. Ben Ray Luján and Michelle Lujan Grisham — applauded the growing wind industry.  The three Members of Congress may differ on a lot of political issues, but here’s one they could all agree on.  I guess it’s true when they say opposites can attract. At least with energy they can.

Energy Grows Pocketbook Confidence

Father and Daughter Sitting in the Kitchen with Bills

Did you know, according to the International Energy Agency (IEA), the U.S. is the number one producer of natural gas in the world, leading Russia, Iran, Canada, and Qatar?  A basic lesson in economics reminds us that when you have a large supply of something, the price is usually pretty low. Natural gas is no different. Right now, one million cubic feet of natural gas trades for less than $3.00.  But how much is a million cubic feet of a gas?  Convert it to gallons and you’re looking at around 32 gallons – the equivalent of a garbage pail you’d put out for your trash collector. That’s a lot of energy for a pretty small price.

But that wasn’t always the case.

Energy prices in the U.S. used to spike when global events, often in the Middle East, would cause a disruption in supply. Now anything from natural disasters like hurricanes, floods, and other unusual changes in weather, capacity constraints from lack of infrastructure or a curve in the supply chain can also interrupt our energy supply. And when there’s a low supply of anything – and in this case energy – the price can get pretty high.

In the last decade, as more natural gas has been produced here in the U.S., the cost of this commodity has plummeted and has also continued to remain relatively low. Experts predict they’ll stay low for a long time and that means utility bills will continue to decrease. That’s good news for small businesses, families and especially low-income households. Individuals and families aren’t just saddled with decisions about whether to go grocery shopping, pick up that medication they need or make rent on time. Often times it’s wondering how they’ll pay the energy bill and keep the lights on.

There is help, and that’s because paying the bills isn’t just hard for a few, it’s hard for a lot of people. Whether it’s food, healthcare or energy, Benefits.gov, a government-run organization has made it their mission to “reduce the expense and difficulty of interacting with the government while increasing citizen access to benefits information.” Their site includes a Benefit Finder with information on energy assistance called the Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program (LIHEAP), which provides support to families for their home energy costs. As they point out, “Home heating is a high-cost basic necessity. For people with low incomes, the decision to pay the utility bill may mean deciding between being warm in the winter or having well-balanced meals.”

In addition to LiHEAP, local utilities also have programs to help people who are having problems paying their energy bills. While each utility is different, it never hurts to look up what programs they can offer, from billing assistance to home energy audits, there are other ways to save.

There are also several state-specific charitable groups that help raise money for families who need assistance with their energy bills. One organization noted total residential natural gas bills for the six winter months (November through April) have dropped from a high of $745 in the 2005-2006 heating season to $475 in the 2012-2013 heating season – a reduction of about 36 percent. That could mean a 50 percent reduction if you follow the trend through to today.  That dramatic decline in natural gas utility bills has made a big difference to many vulnerable seniors, families and disabled people – or simply for people who are living paycheck-to-paycheck. For some households that were unable to pay their utility bills in years past when the price of natural gas was much higher, today they have a better chance of paying those bills due to the availability and price of fuel.

Now, as winter turns to spring, we can thank low-cost natural gas for allowing us to turn down our furnaces and turn up our air conditioners with confidence knowing that low-cost energy will get us through the summer months.

Energy Grows State Partnerships

Construction Workers Talking

We’ve talked before about how traditional fuels like natural gas can partner with renewables like wind and solar as a backup fuel for times when the wind doesn’t blow and the sun doesn’t shine. But energy partnerships can go further than one fuel backing up another.

Partnerships

Without diving too far into a geologic history lesson, fuels like oil, natural gas, and coal are found in significant concentrations in certain parts of the country (hint it has to do with the dinosaur’s final resting places, plate tectonics and ancient island oceans.)

Many states like Washington, Idaho, Upper Midwest and many states along the East Coast don’t produce any natural gas at all. According to the Energy Information Agency (EIA), there are sixteen nonproducing states, which means we have “energy-rich states” and “energy-poor states.”

Contrast that with the Wyoming-Utah-Colorado region of the Rocky Mountains and you’ll see there is a massive abundance of natural gas that is currently being developed. In fact, geologists announced nearly two years ago that Colorado has 40 times more natural gas than previously estimated. Similar discoveries are happening in Pennsylvania too, where estimates of recoverable natural gas jumped to 62.7 trillion cubic feet which means the Keystone state trails only behind Texas – a state nearly five times larger.

The benefit of living in the United States is our ability to work across state lines to share goods, services, and of course, energy.

And that’s great news for people who live in communities in non-producing states, especially because we’ve done such a great job creating safe and efficient ways to deliver energy across the country through an intricate network of pipelines. While energy is still more expensive than energy-producing states, affordability is still within reach.

WalletHub, a credit and wallet surveillance website, taped some of their analysts to compare the total monthly energy bills in each of the 50 states and the District of Columbia. It turns out that besides Hawaii and Alaska, Connecticut, and Massachusetts pay the most for electrify, and guess what? They happen to be three of the sixteen states that don’t produce natural gas. If you compare the EIA’s map of non-producing states and WalletHub’s list of states that pay the most for energy, you’ll see they pretty well line up.  And that’s hardly a coincidence.

Thankfully states are starting to team up in an effort to balance and promote this issue. Recently, Utah and Colorado formed together to create and launch the Western States Rural Natural Gas Initiative, which creates better coordination about where and how to send excess natural gas.  The primary focus is to create a partnership that will help maximize natural gas resources and push them to their fullest potential. The initiative could also focus on long-term planning as well, like where to put charging stations for electric vehicles as the demand for alternative-fueled vehicles grow in popularity.

And just like a balanced energy portfolio, partnerships help states lessen heavy burdens and share benefits more uniformly.

Energy Grows Careers (College Degree Not Required)

Business Owner Taking Notes

If you search online for the top paying jobs in America, you’ll be lead to several lists that include doctors, lawyers, and engineers. Those professions, however, require some key ingredients: long hours, major brainpower and very costly educations. Let’s face it, not everyone is interested or cut out for such extensive degrees, but there is one thing everyone is interested in. Getting a good paycheck!

You may have heard about a lot about high-paying jobs in the energy industry. But aside from the C-suite executives, what kind of jobs are there in energy and can anyone besides upper-management make good money? That’s the question many of us are looking for.

The great news is, it takes all sorts of people with varying skill-sets to make up an industry, but some skill-sets offer more opportunities than others.  The energy industry is no different, but what’s unusual is the number of high-paying jobs that require little or no college degree.

Business Insider recently ranked the Top 40 highest-paying jobs that don’t require a bachelor’s degree and roughly 27% are related to the energy industry. Here’s a quick rundown of energy-related professions and what they pay on average:

 

  • #2 Nuclear power reactor operators. They operate or control nuclear reactors, move control rods, start and stop equipment, monitor and adjust controls, record data in logs, and implement emergency procedures when needed. Median annual wage: $91,170.
  • #5 Power distributors and dispatchers. They coordinate, regulate, or distribute electricity or steam. Median annual wage: $81,900.
  • #7 Nuclear technicians. They assist physicists, engineers, and other professionals in nuclear research and nuclear production. Median annual wage: $79,140.
  • #11 Powerhouse, substation, and relay electrical and electronics repairers. They inspect, test, repair, or maintain electrical equipment in generating stations, substations, and in-service relays. Median annual wage: $75,670.
  • #12 Power plant operators. They control, operate, or maintain machinery to generate electric power. Includes auxiliary equipment operators. Median annual wage: $74,690.
  • #26 Electrical power-line installers and repairers. They install or repair cables or wires used in electrical power or distribution systems. Median annual wage: $68,010.
  • #27 Gas plant operators. They distribute or process gas for utility companies and others by controlling compressors to maintain specified pressures on main pipelines. Median annual wage: $67,580.
  • #28 Petroleum pump system operators, refinery operators, and gaugers. They operate or control petroleum refining or processing units. Median annual wage: $67,400.
  • #37 First-line supervisors of construction trades and extraction workers. They directly supervise and coordinate activities of construction or extraction workers. Median annual wage: $62,980
  • #39 Electrical and electronics engineering technicians. They design, build, repair, calibrate, and modify electrical components, circuitry, controls, and machinery for subsequent evaluation and use by engineering staff. Median annual wage: $62,190.
  • #40 Boilermakers. They assemble, install, and repair boilers, closed vats, and other large vessels or containers that hold liquids and gases. Median annual wage: $62,060.

 

If you read through the whole list, it’ll be hard to find another industry that has this many high-paying middle-class jobs that require little to no college degree. As graduation season approaches, and some high school or junior college students contemplate what’s next, it’s comforting to know that the American energy industry is ready to put them to work and help grow paychecks for individuals and families around the country.

America’s Biggest Oilfield Is Running Out of Pipeline

Money going into gas tank

As reported by CNN, continued pipeline bottlenecks have contributed to spikes in oil prices, leading to cost increases for families and businesses across the nation.

America’s most prolific shale oilfield is pumping so much crude that the pipelines can’t handle it all.

These congestion headaches have contributed to the spike in crude prices by trapping some supplies inside the Permian Basin, the oil-rich West Texas shale field where production has skyrocketed.

Read more – CNN

Energy Grows Exports

Oil tanker at harbor

Many people outside of the energy world may not know this, but the United States has surpassed Russia as the world’s largest natural gas producer.

It’s important to remember what energy production actually means. It means we are drilling for, and “making” natural gas. It’s also important to think about that in terms of consumption.  If we are consuming more than we produce, than we have to continue importing to meet our needs, and vice versa if we are producing more than we consume, we have the ability to export excess natural gas.

When many of us think about exports, we typically think about goods like consumer products, or agricultural products like soybeans, maybe even technology like computers and intellectual property. But rarely if ever do we think about energy. The last time we exported more natural gas than we imported was in 1957. Eisenhower was President, the average cost of new house was $12,220, and Elvis had just released Jailhouse Rock.

Now, over 61 years later, we’re right at the tipping point. The U.S. is transitioning from being a net energy importer to a net exporter because we are producing more than we need.

This places the U.S. in a far better bargaining position on the international stage, especially for our ally countries in Western Europe that receive much of their natural gas from Russia.

And boy does our country know about Russia, especially since it’s been all over the news for the past year. What you may not know about Russia is that one its largest state-owned companies, Gazprom a natural gas company, has routinely been instructed to turn off natural gas to countries across Eastern and Western Europe, who in 2014 made up 40% of the companies revenues. In the past, people in places like Bulgaria, Greece, Macedonia, Croatia, Turkey and Ukraine have all been victims to their lack of energy security, and millions of people suffered, and even died.

Here in the U.S., we have the ability to avoid situations like that because we are not beholden to foreign nations for our energy supplies. That’s due mostly to the Energy Revolution, but also to American ingenuity and the hard-working men and women employed in the energy industry. With these advantages, we have the ability to not only gain energy independence but to help our allies in Eastern and Western Europe when they need energy supplies the most. And it’s not just Europe.

Rick Perry, the Secretary of Energy, recently met with officials in India to discuss exporting liquefied natural gas (LNG) and other forms of energy from the United States to Asia.

“India is obviously a huge market” for United States energy, Secretary Perry has said. “Our ability to deliver U.S. innovation and U.S. natural resources into that country is a great opportunity. That’s the real driving factor of why we’re headed that way. We’re exporting to our allies in Europe the opportunity to truly have a choice of where [they] buy energy from. That’s freedom. And that kind of freedom is priceless,” Perry said.

Energy grows a lot of things, one of those is our economy. It’s also changed our place in the world marketplace in terms of trade and opportunity to help our allies who in many instances didn’t have anywhere else to turn. While there is talk to halt exports by many in the anti-development moment, stopping our ability to help these allies, in the end, it would behoove us to leverage our resources and grow our economy while also helping others. And that’s a good place to be.

Energy Grows Education, but We Also Need to Grow Education about Energy

Elementary school kids climbing on to a school bus

It’s a two-way street when it comes to energy and education. When energy companies develop our natural resources like oil and gas, they pay taxes. Those taxes go by many names such as severance tax, royalties, ad valorem, mill levies and property tax, just to name a few.

Typically, tax revenue from oil and gas development gets placed into to a few different buckets where it ultimately gets divvied up some more. For example, some local communities receive these funds because they see and experience energy development firsthand within their towns and cities. At the local level, that revenue is often used for new or improved roads, bridges, parks, emergency services and schools.

Each community or state handles it a little differently. One shining model often cited is North Dakota. According to Energy North Dakota, in 2014, during the height of the “Bakken Boom,” the industry paid a total of $157 million to the Common Schools Trust Fund. Separately, another ten percent of oil extraction taxes were also deposited each month into the Foundation Aid Stabilization Fund, which had a balance of $588 million as of April 1, 2015, helping to maintain the state’s General Fund while also providing aid to school districts and other educational purposes.

North Dakota residents also passed an initiative to create a Legacy Fund to keep pace with the growth energy development has brought them. Between 2010-2016, North Dakota socked away more than $4 billion strictly from taxes on oil and gas development. This year, their lawmakers started debating how to spend the $300 million in interest earnings the fund generates annually. That’s right; they aren’t even tapping the fund, just the interest it has accrued.  In lean years, North Dakota has the benefit of tapping the Legacy Fund instead of raising taxes on its citizens.

Stories like this can be replicated in other states and communities too and it’s starting to look like New Mexico could have the opportunity to mirror North Dakota. The Permian Basin, America’s latest prolific oil basin, which straddles the New Mexico-Texas border, has been home to oil development for more than a century. The recent uptick in New Mexico is comparatively new. A recent report by the nonpartisan New Mexico Tax Research Institute confirmed that New Mexico’s General Fund has enlarged and public schools are set to benefit from $1.743 billion in revenue generated from oil and gas taxes. The report also shows $711 million in funding for public schools, and nearly $223 million for the state’s universities, colleges, and other higher education institutions.

One thing is for sure – energy grows education. But when it comes to energy and education it’s a two-way street.  Simply put, not enough people know how much energy supports our schools, which means we need to grow education about energy. And that’s what our Campaign for America’s Energy is all about, making communities more aware of energy and the many benefits it brings us.