The Cost of Indecision

energy

Energy is the lifeblood of just about everything we experience in our daily lives. It is so intertwined into what we do and use each day. We often don’t even know what it is that could be affected if energy came to a screeching halt. It’s a real paradox of our modern existence. From the fuel that moves us (planes, trains and automobiles) to the power that keeps us going (food, shelter and medicine), we need and use energy all the time. How we use energy though is not always clear.

So What are we Talking About?

Let’s start here. When it comes to transporting energy like oil and natural gas, experts agree the safest, most efficient, and environmentally friendly way to do so is through a pipeline. Why? Pipelines don’t need drivers, they never cause traffic, and they don’t need rest. That’s why we rely on them so much, and with more than 2.4 million miles of pipelines under our feet, pipelines move the critical energy we all need and use to where it needs to go. We don’t EVER have to think about it.

Much like our roads, highways and bridges, pipelines need to be maintained to ensure they have the latest technology and materials to ensure their safety. Line 3 in Minnesota, which was built in the 1960s, is part of a network of pipelines that runs from Alberta, Canada, across northern Minnesota, through Wisconsin to its final destination in Superior.

But Why Update?

Both segments in Canada and Wisconsin have been modernized. All that remains is the connecting portion of the pipeline that runs through North Dakota and across Minnesota. While we never think about pipelines when we’re brushing our teeth, watching TV or making dinner; this $2.9 billion connecting pipeline is the nervous system of the Upper Peninsula region.

How Else Does Energy Affect Us?

You see, pipelines aren’t just about energy; they’re about people too. 358 people to be exact. Yes, those are permanent jobs and a whole lot of salaries that come with those jobs. Believe it or not, when you calculate the wages of those individuals and how they spend their paychecks, it adds up to about $30 million back into the local economy. How? Employees spend their paychecks near where they live and help keep local and small business going. Which ultimately keeps others in business and employing more people within the community

On top of that, during the construction of the Line 3 Replacement Project, about 8,600 temporary jobs in Minnesota will be created. In terms of economic impact that’s around $334 million in paychecks to workers. Not to mention, a $162 million construction-related gains for local economies.

Why Aren’t We Moving Forward?

Unfortunately, some still aren’t convinced, nor do they care. The reality is there is a small group of people who will continue to delay the construction of this pipeline project. Through lawyers (sue tactics using taxpayer money – your money) and other political means in an effort to ultimately shut down construction.

Don’t get us wrong, maintenance, and ensured safety for our pipelines is very important. No matter if we’re talking about your home furnace, vehicle or any other appliance that needs maintained; without updates, we run unnecessary risks and increased costs. A pipeline is no different.

But sometimes the most expensive decisions are the ones we don’t make. Indecision is expensive. Just think of the last time you said to yourself, “Wow – that was an expensive mistake.”

While we continue to review the same information for Line 3 over and over again, thousands of construction jobs and 358 of our friends and neighbors are sitting and waiting.

We need to replace this vital piece of energy infrastructure that delivers affordable, reliable energy to Minnesotans today — and will continue to do so well into the future.

It’s time to move forward – for our communities and Minnesota.

3 Guesses on How Minnesota Will Make Up Its $30 Million Shortfall

taxes
Why So Many Taxes?

If you sit and think about it, sometimes it feels like we pay a lot of taxes, doesn’t it?

Taxes at the mall, when we’re out to eat, on our paychecks. Taxes are everywhere, and it’s probably why people always vote against them or are skeptical when policymakers bring them up.

If you’re a homeowner, then you probably know that part of your monthly mortgage bill includes property taxes. But where do these taxes go? Well, there are gobs of areas where taxes are used. Besides improving the community, like funding for roads and transportation systems, health and wellness recreation centers, and more; property taxes also go to educate children— the future of our great state.

Who Else Supports our Systems?

While it may feel like it, parents and homeowners aren’t the only ones that fund our education system, many businesses do, too. A big funder to our education system here in the state happens to be the energy industry. The funds aren’t just a couple bucks here and there, it’s millions if not hundreds of millions depending on where you live. For some communities, this is funding that can truly make a difference in their area.

That’s because the taxes that are paid are usually connected to a part of the business operations. Office space, payroll and pipeline infrastructure are just a few that come to mind. An active industry is usually a revenue generating one, too. The energy industry is certainly no stranger to paying large sums of taxes either.

When a Political Process Can Interfere with Funding

When a business or industry is stuck within a political process, it can’t do as much for the community. The Line 3 Pipeline Replacement Project is a great example. In 2018, Enbridge, the operator of the Line 3 pipeline, paid more than $30 million – something they do every year – in property taxes across Minnesota. These taxes are for various pipelines and related facilities, such as terminals, storage facilities and pump stations. Those tax dollars could come to a screeching halt if the Line 3 Replacement Project is shut down; like some anti-energy activists are persuading local officials to do.

We know that Minnesotans are a savvy bunch, and always have been when it comes to choices that affect communities in our state. It’s no more evident than looking to something as simple as the latest U.S. News and World Report, ranking Minnesota the third best state in the nation. The rankings evaluated all 50 states based on criteria such as health care, education, economy and infrastructure, and Minnesota is the only state to rank in the top three each of the past three years.

Keeping Minnesota’s Tax Funding

It’s hard to believe Minnesota will continue that trend if significant tax dollars for education start to dry up due to denials created by political fighting and misplaced judgments about the Line 3 Replacement Project.

We suppose we could give you three guesses on how Minnesota might make up this $30 million tax shortfall if Line 3 goes away, but revenue-generating you only need one.

North Carolina Emissions Fell By as Much as 92 Percent as the State Continues to Grow

Raleigh, North Carolina

Raleigh, NC. – Given that North Carolina remains one of the nation’s largest energy consumers, the fact that statewide emissions have fallen by as much as 92 percent since 1990 is a fantastic achievement, according to a Consumer Energy Alliance (CEA) analysis released today.

This historic and underreported trend comes as organizations and outlets continue to disregard the significant work that has been done across the country, and in North Carolina, to reduce emissions. This analysis demonstrates that we can have energy production, expanded pipeline infrastructure, and create sound environmental stewardship at the same time.

This number is noteworthy as the state has no significant production, but has continued to be the fourth highest state in the nation in residential electricity consumption. The state also grew its gross state economy by 305 percent and boasted the largest manufacturing workforce in the southeast, and the 8th largest in the United States – employing more than 460,000 workers.

This is a critical factor in the data from 1990-2017 that CEA examined, which show North Carolina’s emissions of key pollutants have decreased across the board, with a:

• 69 percent reduction in nitrogen oxides (NOx),
• 92 percent reduction in sulfur dioxide (SO2),
• 58 percent reduction in volatile organic compounds (VOCs), and

Further, these trends occurred natural gas has been primarily responsible for powering the state with 30 percent of electricity generation statewide relying on natural gas, and with one in four North Carolina homes relying on the fuel for home heating.

“What we’ve seen in North Carolina is a leading example of the national trend that even though population, economic activity and electricity use have grown significantly, emissions are down across the board,” said Kevin Doyle, Vice President of State Affairs for CEA. “This is a factor of advanced technology, energy efficiency and the dedication our communities have to uphold our state’s environmental standards.”

This analysis follows CEA’s Energy Savings Report for North Carolina, which found that families, small business and manufacturers across the state saved almost $12 billion thanks to low-cost energy over the past decade. The analysis details how the state achieved those feats despite having no significant in-state energy production while facing substantial demand from consumers.

On average, each resident of North Carolina spent $2,992 to meet their energy needs in 2017. With 14 percent of the state’s population living at or below the poverty line, this translates to almost one in every four dollars of their income going toward energy expenses.

To view the analysis, click here.

###

About Consumer Energy Alliance
Consumer Energy Alliance (CEA) is the leading consumer advocate for energy, bringing together families, farmers, small businesses, distributors, producers, and manufacturers to support America’s environmentally sustainable energy future. With more than 550,000 members nationwide, our mission is to help ensure stable prices and energy security for households and businesses across the country. CEA works daily to encourage people across the nation to seek sensible, realistic, and environmentally responsible solutions to meet our energy needs.

Contact:
Emily Haggstrom
P: 720-582-0242
ehaggstrom@consumerenergyalliance.org

How Do You Like to Give Back?

give back
What’s Your Passion Project?

Whether you’re passionate about helping at animal shelters, food banks, or hospitals, we all have something inside that gets us involved with our communities.

Studies show that volunteering can enrich a person’s life, connect them with their communities, and offer a new perspective and understanding about how we fit into the world around us. Universally, volunteers say their work helps them gain a unique sense of purpose by serving those around them. A benefit that often manifests in other areas of their lives. For this reason, many businesses encourage their employees to volunteer and give back to the communities where they live and work. The benefits it produces are tangible.

Financial donations can also be a great way to give back. Nowadays, charities offer numerous ways to give financially. From the click of a button, text message, phone call, or by initiating a reoccurring monthly pledge to help make a difference.

While there are few guarantees in life, it’s a safe bet that volunteering or donating in support of a cause you are passionate about is something you will never regret.

Some Make it A Livelihood

Take, for example, Bill Gates. While he is best known as the co-founder of Microsoft, he and his wife Melinda are now role models for philanthropic causes. Launching their foundation dedicated to healthcare, education, and ending poverty around the world. Their foundation issues grants for initiatives and programs across the globe, focusing on agricultural development, emergency relief, and more.

But these committed organizations can’t exist without the support of generous people – not just billionaires, it’s people like you and me.

Minnesota Gives the Most

With a record number of non-profits and charities striving to make life better; topping the list of most charitable states is – drum roll please – Minnesota.

WalletHub, a personal finance website, crunched the numbers to determine the most charitable states in the country. They ranked them using 18 different indicators across two distinct categories: volunteering, service and charitable giving. Specifically, they took into account data on things like volunteer hours per capita and share of population collecting and distributing food. They also measured income donated, share of sheltered homeless, and Google Search interest for “charitable donations.” Minnesota came out on top. It’s not just because individuals gave, the businesses in our communities do too.

Including Local Businesses

Enbridge, is a shining example of an organization that showcases what a committed, passionate and motivated employee base within an organization can do through giving back. They invested $413,500 in community-strengthening initiatives across Minnesota — and supported numerous not-for-profit agencies aligned with their core focus areas in 2018 alone. That’s just a fraction of what they did across the country in areas where their employees live and work.

Across the U.S., Enbridge invested more than $4.6 million in communities near their pipelines, projects and facilities. They supported initiatives that focus on health and safety, environment, and community. As well as through various employee-driven United Way campaigns, which raised nearly $6.1 million for worthy causes. Through their Our Community Partners program, Enbridge employees volunteered approximately 11,400 hours for causes they care about. Projects that focused on improving quality of life in communities.

Why Is This So Important?

Unfortunately, this work and its funding could seriously be blocked if the restoration of the Line 3 pipeline is delayed or stopped in Minnesota. And if their employee base shrinks (or even disappears), that will hurt the local communities and non-profits they help and support even more. For those of us that are grateful for investments within our communities; the work that is being done and the funding that’s being contributed to our disadvantaged populations. Considering what could be at stake is extremely unfortunate to say the least.

So the next time you hear about the proposed modernization project, remember that it’s not just about the energy being delivered. It’s about the people and the support for our communities that have a stake right alongside that pipeline too.

Why Minnesota Farmers and Ranchers Support the Line 3 Replacement Project

farmers
Happiness is Property

“Life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness” is perhaps the most famous phrase in the Declaration of Independence, but did you know it was almost something else? Believe it or not, the term happiness may have initially been property?

Conventional history, popular wisdom, and of course, countless scholars often attribute the phrase’s originality to John Locke’s “life, liberty, and property.”

Jefferson was well aware of Locke’s writings on government, but the change certainly seems more grand and inclusive since not everyone is keen on owning a home nowadays – for some, the flexibility and freedom of not being tied to an expensive mortgage is more their idea of the American dream. Add to it skyrocketing home prices, unusually high student debt and less loan availability as a few of the reasons millennials (and many others) today aren’t buying homes at the rate of previous generations.

Nonetheless, property rights are a pretty unique concept and something most Americans respect and hold dear, whether you’re a titleholder or not. The right to own something and do what you want (within reason) is in many ways the definition of freedom.

“Within reason” Is the Key Phrase Here

In an ironic twist of words, rules and regulations actually set us free. By having a framework of what we can (or cannot) do with our own land or property makes it all work. For example, if you live in a traditional suburban neighborhood, your next-door neighbor cannot legally open up a night club ushering in patrons at all hours of the night. Likewise, you cannot turn your home garage into an auto-repair business and double park customer vehicles up and down the street. Rules allowing (and prohibiting) certain practices actually give us freedom to be…neighbors.

And that’s fine for most of us because we aren’t looking to turn our homes into a major place of commerce or a strip mall.

When Property IS Your Income

But what about the folks who lie outside of those restrictions? Like the people who rely on their property for their livelihood? Many of them are farmers and ranchers – 1.3% of America that raises most of our food. Their home, are both where they rest their heads and where they run their business, which means they should have a right to choose what they do with their land, right? It seems like the logical answer.

It should be, but farmers aren’t price setters, they’re price takers, which means the market dictates what their crop is worth. Despite funding from the Farm Bill before harvest, many farmers have to put their faith in a good season with the right conditions to make a profit. While some do, many don’t. It’s a thankless job to ensure Americans have the food they need on their dinner tables each night. So often, farmers have to find supplementary means of income (we like to call this a side hustle) to make ends meet during some down years.

Depending where they’re located, farmers and landowners across the country are turning to energy development and infrastructure to help make those ends meet. Whether it is traditional energy development, wind or pipeline titleholder, royalty income and leases help supplement what might otherwise be a bad season, or be the money to send a kid to school while still keeping the farm profitable.

Why Pipelines Matter

Arguably, farmers and ranchers care more about their land than anybody else. They’ve sunk their blood, sweat, tears and money into these farms – some for generations – and still, many Minnesota farmers and landowners have come out in support of the Line 3 Replacement project. Why?  Because pipelines are the safest and most efficient way to transport energy across their properties to its intended destinations – usually refineries that make gasoline to power our vehicles, jet fuel to fly us to the places we need (and want) to get to and the products that make our life, liberty and pursuit of happiness, possible.

Delaying or denying this pipeline replacement puts farmers and ranchers – their economic livelihood and their safety – at risk and jeopardizes Minnesotans food sources, too. And that’s an unreasonable request to make.

Paris Climate Pact, U.S. Reaching Goals Despite Pulling Out

Eiffel Tower

The U.S. pull out from the Paris Climate Pact has caused quite a stir among politicians and extreme “advocacy” groups. Regardless of the uproar, facts are facts.

“Clear and compelling facts that continue to go under-reported: With or without the Paris pact, the United States is already leading the world in emissions reductions and is more than half way toward reaching its goals under the accord.”

The U.S. has been reported as reducing twice as much carbon dioxide than any other nation in 2017. A year that we made the single-largest reduction of CO2. Many states continue to drop emissions, despite energy usage growth. Throwing fits about pulling out of the agreement are null and void when the numbers are decreasing without signing.

Read more – Morning Consult

Too Much Pressure on Line 5 Could Hurt Michigan’s Auto Industry

Building a Car Engine

Manufacturing has been the backbone of Michigan’s economy since Henry Ford built his first plant in Highland Park. That’s why you – and just about everyone else in the country – think about manufacturing here. It’s impossible to avoid including the auto industry.

The Detroit Chamber of Commerce has said that more than two million cars and trucks rolled off 11 assembly lines across the Detroit region in 2017. Including suppliers, there are over 1,600 automotive-related manufacturing establishments here in the state.

But every industry is only as strong as its weakest link. From union strikes and trade wars to tariffs and material shortages (like steel), the auto industry is susceptible to numerous threats, which we’ve seen time and time again.

The Center for Automotive Research (CAR) projects that consumers could be looking at price increases soon, as much as $1,300 for a typical vehicle and as much as $5,800 for a luxury vehicle. In line with the new CAR study, IHS forecasts U.S. new vehicle sales could plunge by 2 million vehicles annually, to 16.5 million a year from 2019 to 2025.

That could severely hurt Michigan commuters.

The vast majority of our automobiles can’t run without supplies of affordable fuel, right?

A case can certainly be made for electric vehicles (EV) picking up the slack left by less oil on the market, but for now, there are only about one million EVs on the road in the U.S. This significant milestone was achieved in October of 2018. That’s great news, but there’s still a lot of work to be done to increase that number and expand our nations charging infrastructure since it faces many of the same regulatory, policy, and market hurdles that any energy project faces, whether it be solar, wind, natural gas or other utility projects.

The expansion of EVs is impressive and came after the culmination of billions of dollars in automaker investment, tax credits paid directly to purchasers, state mandates, and cash assistance from the federal government and years of expanding the nationwide charging infrastructure.

In fact, there are now about one million EVs on the road in the U.S. This major milestone was achieved in October of 2018. That’s great news, but there’s still a lot of work to be done to increase that number and expand our nation’s charging infrastructure since it faces many of the same regulatory, policy, and market hurdles that any energy project faces, whether it be solar, wind, natural gas or other utility projects.

It is also important to note that, while one million total EVs on the road sounds like a lot, there are still roughly 272.5 million registered vehicles in the U.S.

So while its positive news to see emerging technology improve the range of EVs and their deployment the reality is we are going to need a lot of traditional transportation fuels like gasoline and diesel for years to come – cars aren’t going to disappear tomorrow.

That means if you care about Michigan’s auto industry and all the jobs that go along with it, you ought to care about Line 5. The Line 5 pipeline transports about 23 million gallons of oil and natural gas a day through the Upper Peninsula, including a four-mile stretch through the Straits of Mackinac. Currently, the State, its agencies, and the pipeline’s owner, Enbridge, are preparing for a $500 million upgrade to construct a tunnel that will house a new pipeline so that they can continue to safely transport oil under the Straits – the main ingredient in gasoline – to the destinations it needs to reach, like refineries.

Sound like a smart idea? You’re not the only one – more than half of all Michiganders support the idea too, according to a recent survey commissioned by the Michigan Chamber of Commerce.

Unfortunately, there’s been a lot of talk, and even more political posturing lately, about putting pressure on ending Line 5 or making it so difficult that it be entirely relocated. That may sound good in a speech or at a press conference, but the reality is it will negatively impact our state economy, our wallets and how our community accesses energy.

With looming price increases on one of Michigan’s most important industries, let’s not end Line 5, instead, let’s continue to use it, and send energy where it needs to go the most.

As the holidays are approaching, and families prepare to travel to their loved ones, we can’t afford to continue the back and forth on this project that will ultimately only hurt Michigan and its communities.

Cuomo’s Carbon Casualties

Taxis in New York City

In today’s war on climate change, some state administrations are focused on overhauling their states into a world that lacks adequate energy solutions as they charge forward towards unrealistic energy mandates that limit certain types of energy. The problem lies that most electric grids –  particularly in large cities – are not set up for the overhaul. In a rush to change these policies, politicians are forgetting that consumers are the ones suffering the consequences of these decisions.

“One irony is that the pipeline he vetoed below New York Harbor could reduce annual CO2 emissions by the equivalent of 500,000 cars on the road. His gas embargo is raising state emissions.”

Read more – Wall Street Journal

The Flu – Coming to an Office Near You

Woman Fighting Cold

Your co-worker Larry is at it again this year. The sniffling, the coughing, the sneezing. It is enough to drive you crazy, but mostly, you’re hoping that he’s been kind enough to de-germ everything in the office he’s touched. It’s cold and flu season for crying out loud, and it’s the worst.

If you’re like most people, we’re all hoping to avoid the doctor (you can find some tips here,) and as a result, we arm ourselves with over-the-counter medicines, tissues and disinfectants. While I’m sure you’ve thought about how they’ll improve your miserable condition, have you ever thought about how much energy goes into making these products and ensuring their availability when you need them? Let’s dig in.

Gel Caps

It starts with the telltale signs, and then you know the drill. Your nose starts getting stuffy, and your throat is dry and sore. You reach for your favorite “get you through the night, so you can hopefully feel better in the morning” medication. Typically, they come in gel caps.

From the laboratory to the store and into your medicine cabinet, the amount of energy used to get you those gel caps comes in many forms. Any given laboratory in the U.S. consumes 5 to 10 times more energy per square foot than a typical office building. Add in a clean room (where most pharmaceuticals are made), and you’re looking at up to 50 times more energy consumed, though it’s getting better. However, that doesn’t even account for the lab coats, specialized flooring, and equipment needed in the labs, nor the energy to manufacture them and transport them to your store of choice.

Tissues

The grandmothers of the world reusing old Kleenex are the true champions of energy efficiency when it comes to tissue use. You know the one that goes back into their pocket or purse, only to be dug out and used again later. While more manufacturers are working toward energy-saving solutions, the fact is, tissue demand worldwide is growing. In the meantime, think about utilizing a handkerchief; it’s also pretty trendy.

Disinfectant

Over the last decade, several companies have jumped on the “eco-friendly” bandwagon. However, knowing if your cleaning products are indeed “green” almost takes a Ph.D. Similar to the health food industry, labels aren’t always what they seem, and the most narrow of margins can lead you to believe you’re green when you really aren’t. Finding a product that is environmentally sound and kills germs is getting easier, but it can still be an obnoxious task. In the meantime, most of us prefer the tried and true products that will ensure we won’t be sick into next year.

Though these are just three things that help us get back to feeling better, there are many other medicines and remedies we use that are dependent on traditional energy products to create. From your Vapor Rub and Chapstick to cough drops and thermometers, being sick takes a lot of energy – and not just to get up off the couch or out of bed to find the things that make us feel better.

7,000 Nycha Residents Go Without Heat or Hot Water As Temps Dip

New York park in winter

Thousands of residents in New York City went without heat or hot water last Friday as the city experienced the coldest temperatures this season, dipping into the 30s. As temperatures continue to drop in the coming months, it is vital that New Yorkers can count on the energy they need to stay warm. This is yet another example of how blocking essential pipeline infrastructure in the state hurts residents and creates unsafe and unacceptable conditions for those counting on heating their homes in the cold winter months.

More than 7,000 New York City Housing Authority residents went without heat or hot water Friday in six developments in the Bronx, Manhattan and Brooklyn. Tenants in at least 3,138 apartments experienced the unplanned outages Friday, according to NYCHA’s website…’We have a lot of seniors there. They’re saying their cold,’ McNear said. ‘I don’t know how to help them. I don’t want them burning their stoves because that’s a hazard, but they’re cold.’

Read more – NY Daily News