Energy Explorer: Investor Owned Utilities, Energy Efficiency and the Future of Electricity

Smart Thermostat Temperature

Ultimately, consumers drive the market, but it is also in the best interest of utilities to be responsive to that market and new policies set by the states where they operate. While some have focused more on dedicating resources to see energy savings in low-income areas, others are focused on improving the quality of their grids for the addition of Distributed Energy Resources (DERs), while others have implemented plans for increased renewable infrastructure and other forms of clean energy to meet state mandates and local demand.

When people think of utilities, you often think closest to home. However, did you know there are multiple companies and organizations that provide power based on where you live? Some are large Investor Owned Utilities (IOUs) – like NextEra Energy, Duke Energy, and Southern Company who have service territories and subsidiaries all across the United States, serving 72% of U.S. electricity customers. Others are smaller like Rural Electric Cooperatives that serve only 42 million people but power 56% of the nation’s landmass. Even smaller, are municipally owned power providers whose total customers add up to 49 million Americans, but they are dispersed amongst homes and businesses in 2,000 municipal communities around the country representing a much smaller footprint.

While they all provide a service their customer’s needs, the vast majority of power comes from IOUs in large cities across America. This is where some of the biggest impacts to meet state mandates will come from as they plan to diversify the power they provide and the timeline for how they will meet their goals. This comes with plans for utility-scale development that people are seeing all across the U.S.

While large market IOUs like the ones listed above can make some of the most sweeping changes due to their resources, market cap, and economies of scale, they do not have the economy of scope. That is where the mid-market IOUs have more flexibility, nimbleness, and deep knowledge of their service territories to meet customer needs and help them understand just what they can do as individuals to reduce their environmental footprint. We have picked five utilities that are doing just that.

  1. Oklahoma Gas and Electric (OG&E) – Customers: <858,000

Outside of being the first utility in Oklahoma to offer wind power in the early 2000s and the first to develop a universal solar farm. Their transmission infrastructure upgrades have helped them take Oklahoma to the third most wind-producing state in the nation. The utility has started converting old coal plants to natural gas, modernized aging equipment to assist with the incorporation of new renewable generation technologies, and enhanced its grid reliability.

OG&E’s focus is on cutting emissions by voluntarily investing in technology and education that helps customers in its service territory by joining energy efficiency programs, monitoring usage, and providing weatherization and home energy audit services. Combined with these efforts, the company is also expanding its renewable footprint and adding battery storage as it becomes available.

  1. South Jersey Gas (SJI) – Customers – Customers <700,000

Serving seven counties in Southern New Jersey, SJI is putting its money where its mouth is by committing at least 25% of its annual capital expenditures on sustainability projects and taking its service territory to carbon neutrality by 2040. The company created an internal team responsible for replacing aging infrastructure to reduce escaping emissions, upgrading leak detection technology, converting its service vehicles, and adding solar to its facilities.

On the ground in its service territory, the utility has significantly expanded their energy efficiency programs, is working to provide consumers with new tools to help them reduce their energy consumption, and are investing in several clean and renewable energy technologies such as renewable natural gas (RNG), green hydrogen and high-efficiency fuel cells.

  1. Alabama Power – Customers: <1 million

This utility is clearly focused on Environmental Social and Governance as it lays out its Smart Energy Plan, which includes renewable development and R&D, fostering innovation, and instituting more inclusion. It’s what they’re doing ‘beyond the meter’ that is going to make the biggest difference by investing in more clean energy technology like nuclear, hydropower, and other renewables.

For those that want to support the work the utility is doing by investing in renewables, the organization is offering customers access to their Renewable Energy Credit program. This program is designed for those who may not be able to afford residential solar or live in an urban area where close access to renewables is not possible. The company is also heavily investing in research and development as well as transitioning its fleet vehicles.

  1. Public Service Company of New Mexico (PNM) – Customers: ~800,000

In 2019, PNM announced its Path to 100 to coincide with the shuttering of its coal San Juan Generating Station and the passage of the Energy Transition Act, which requires state utilities to be emissions-free by 2045. As the fifth-largest state in the nation, the utility is making substantial investments in its energy infrastructure to transport the growing wind and solar in the state while also focusing on geothermal.

The organization is working to reduce the strain on its customers by contributing the investment costs of the coal plant and is planning to export its renewable energy to other states to bring savings to its own customers. With a smaller state population but larger geography, helping its rural populations by expanding its grid infrastructure will be crucial to meeting its energy goals.

  1. UGI Utilities – Customers: ~700,000

In its latest report titled, The Foundation of a Renewable energy Future, UGI has committed to identifying opportunities that will help the organization reduce its emissions by 55% over the next five years. The utility is aiming to complete this ambitious goal through low to zero-carbon alternatives such as compressed natural gas (CNG), Renewable Natural Gas from livestock and landfills, as well as transitioning their fleet vehicles to reduce their organizational footprint.

As the utility works to lower its carbon footprint they are working to do so without added costs or disruptions to consumers. Their plan also calls for increased storage and diversification of the types of energy it will offer. This means updating their staff to ensure everyone is on the same page as it concerns safety and increased demand from its customers.

Natural Gas Service Ban Could Cost Virginians Over $26,000 Per Household

Natural gas used for cooking

RICHMOND, VA – Consumer Energy Alliance (CEA), the leading energy and environmental advocate for families and businesses, today released a report that finds that a natural gas ban would cost every household in Virginia more than $26,000.

The report, “The Hidden Costs of a Virginia Natural Gas Ban,” examines the impact of a natural gas ban if it were forced onto families and Virginians. Using open-source consumer data, CEA developed a cost calculator to provide an estimate of what a typical household in Richmond could expect to pay as a result of policies to ban natural gas service and use, depending on home configuration, appliances used and other factors.

These findings dovetail with previous research performed by CEA which found that the cost to replace just major gas appliances in homes nationwide would be more than $258 billion. The report also found that attempts to “electrify everything” would require a massive infrastructure buildout of over $100 billion in the state.

With one in three Virginia households using natural gas for home heating, banning natural gas would be financially devastating to families who would have to pay upwards of $26,000 to involuntarily reconfigure their home and purchase new appliances. A ban on natural gas would also disproportionately harm the 9.9% of Virginians who live at or below the poverty level, those on fixed incomes, and businesses still recovering from the economic hardships of COVID-19; as energy bills will inevitably increase,” CEA Vice President of State Affairs Kevin Doyle said.

Doyle added: “Natural gas is a critical resource for fueling Virginia’s families and businesses, but it has also been pivotal in the remarkable reductions in emissions that the state has achieved in recent years. Significant emissions reductions have occurred in Virginia while natural gas use has increased and expanded.”

“Virginians want affordable, reliable, secure, and sustainable energy to power their businesses, homes, and communities. This CEA report clearly demonstrates that banning natural gas from the market as a fuel or a feedstock fails this consumer test. Clean natural gas must be part of our future,” said Brett Vassey, President and CEO of the Virginia Manufacturers Association.

Doyle added: “Misguided attempts to ban energy services will only lead to undue financial burdens on Virginia’s families, seniors, small businesses and manufacturers and work against our environmental and climate goals. Consumers should retain the right to keep the energy service they want and choose appliances they wish to use – not activists with ill-considered agendas that put families last.”

To view the report, click here. The Virginia Report is part of a series of CEA reports on the impact natural gas bans would have on states. For more, click here.

###

About Consumer Energy Alliance
Consumer Energy Alliance (CEA) is the leading voice for sensible energy and environmental policies for consumers, bringing together families, farmers, small businesses, distributors, producers, and manufacturers to support America’s environmentally sustainable energy future. With more than 550,000 members nationwide, we are committed to leading the nation’s dialogue around energy, its critical role in the economy, and how it supports the vital supply chains for the families and businesses that depend on them. CEA works daily to encourage communities across the nation to seek sensible, realistic, and environmentally responsible solutions to meet our nation’s energy needs.

Contact:
Bryson Hull
(202) 657-2855
bhull@consumerenergyalliance.org

CEA’s Top 5 Favorite Energy Stories This Week – July 30

A bipartisan infrastructure package is still on the horizon. Senate majority Leader Chuck Schumer said yesterday that he has the votes to move the $3.5 trillion package forward.

In other Capitol Hill news this week, Interior Secretary Deb Haaland confirmed that the Interior Department hopes to release their interim report on their review of oil, gas and coal leasing on federal lands and offshore waters very soon.

Meanwhile, gas prices are still high across the country with supply and demand being a key determining factor in the price of gas.

Want more energy news? Check out our top five news stories for the week below!

 

5New geothermal energy technology revolutionizing industry

Researchers have developed a new airlift approach to optimize geothermal pump technologies. WVU Today explains that this improved design will help to eliminate the line shaft pump, which creates limitations.

4The future of solar energy could be stick-on panels

Researchers are focused on the future of solar panels and how stick-on panels could help to bring solar power to more people. Electrek discusses the benefits of this new, lighter, and easier to install solar technology; and how the EU is supporting its growth. 

3Meet the world’s most powerful floating turbine

The Orbital Marine Power’s launch of the O2, the world’s most powerful floating turbine, is predicted to generate 2MW of energy. Slash Gear highlights how the O2 would be able to power 2000 homes with a 2200 carbon offset with energy captured from flowing tidal energy. 

2A new use for carbon dioxide

Italy’s Energy Dome is attempting to turn the previous problem of carbon dioxide into a solution by utilizing a system of condensing and expanding the compound to store energy at half the price of lithium batteries. New Atlas describes the process behind a new form of energy storage to disentangle the constant need for energy spiking and the global energy grid. 

1Lithium or hydrogen batteries being used in commercial vehicles?

Though hydrogen batteries provide longer durability and mileage capacity, users face limited availability as many countries are not equipped for a hydrogen charging network. Money Control writes about how to decipher the benefits and costs of using hydrogen over lithium batteries for transportation vehicles.

Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee Should Consider Environmental, Climate and Energy Goals in Examining DOI Budget for FY 2022

US Capitol Building

WASHINGTON, D.C.Consumer Energy Alliance (CEA), the leading energy and environmental advocate for families and businesses, released the following statement as the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee met today to examine the Department of Interior’s fiscal year 2022 budget:

“As Senators meet to discuss President Biden’s budget request for the U.S. Department of Interior for fiscal year 2022, we urge lawmakers to remember the significant funding that is generated for our environment and national parks from renewable and traditional energy production on federal lands and waters,” CEA Federal Affairs Advisor Michael Zehr said.

“Thanks to the Great American Outdoors Act (GAOA), the Gulf of Mexico Energy Security Act (GOMESA) and the Land and Water Conservation Fund (LWCF), our country’s national parks, water resources, coasts and environment are funded in large part by revenue earned by the federal government from renewable and traditional energy development on federal lands and waters.”

“That is why it is imperative that the Biden Administration and the Department of Interior lift the moratorium on new federal leases, and quickly offer a clear, competitive path forward to continue America’s energy and environmental leadership. The United States has some of the most environmentally friendly energy production standards in the world. If we hope to achieve our environmental and climate goals, expanded responsible U.S. domestic production on federal lands is the safest, fastest and most efficient way to get there.”

“Also, as we move forward with the energy transition, the U.S. has the opportunity to be a leader in renewable power generation and energy storage. For critical minerals and rare earth elements essential to these efforts, it is vital that the U.S. increase critical mineral development on federal lands and work with allies to secure these resources rather than relying on foreign suppliers like China, who do not share our democratic values or our commitment to environmentally responsible development.”

“CEA also strongly supports expanded development of offshore wind. As the country strives to achieve 30 gigawatts of offshore wind capacity by 2030 as outlined by President Biden, the Department of Interior will need to allocate additional funding for more staff in order to process the increase in permits needed. CEA supports an investment in the Department’s staff in order to ensure the permitting process is efficient and orderly and to ensure the nation’s ambitious goal is not hampered unnecessary bottlenecks.”

“The United States is a proven leader in developing affordable and reliable energy, produced in a safe and environmentally responsible manner. We hope the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee will consider this along with our environmental, climate and energy goals as they examine budget considerations for the Department of Interior.”

###

About Consumer Energy Alliance
Consumer Energy Alliance (CEA) is the leading voice for sensible energy and environmental policies for consumers, bringing together families, farmers, small businesses, distributors, producers, and manufacturers to support America’s environmentally sustainable energy future. With more than 550,000 members nationwide, we are committed to leading the nation’s dialogue around energy, its critical role in the economy, and how it supports the vital supply chains for the families and businesses that depend on them. CEA works daily to encourage communities across the nation to seek sensible, realistic, and environmentally responsible solutions to meet our nation’s energy needs.

Contact:
Bryson Hull
(202) 657-2855
bhull@consumerenergyalliance.org

Consumer Energy Alliance Member Testifies Before Congress to Share Harmful Impacts of Supply Chain Disruptions and Rising Energy Costs to Small Businesses

Pennsylvania Avenue and United States Capitol

Washington, D.C.Consumer Energy Alliance (CEA) Federal Affairs Adviser Michael Zehr today thanked CEA’s member Tom Greer for his important testimony before the House Small Business Committee Subcommittee on Innovation, Entrepreneurship, and Workforce Development at a hearing entitled “Wealth for the Working Class: The Clean Energy Economy.” As the owner-operator of Hub City Brewing Company in Belen, New Mexico, Greer shared his perspective of how everything from overregulation and supply chain issues to energy cost increases have a negative effect on America’s small businesses.

“As we strive to reach our nation’s economic and environmental aspirations and expand the availability of low-emission energy production from renewables, advanced nuclear and hydro, we must also improve the efficiency and overall emissions from traditional fuels. Such a balanced approach is needed by virtually every aspect of our economy, from small businesses – like Tom Greer’s brewery – to agriculture, steel manufacturing and textiles,” Zehr said.

“We thank Tom for shedding light on the many challenges our small businesses across the nation are facing. These staples of our communities are always hurt by rising energy costs, which go right to their bottom lines,” Zehr said. “It’s important to keep in mind the role lower-emitting traditional energy sources will play in our energy future, along with advanced technologies and renewables, to help ensure our communities, families and small businesses’ day-to-day economic and energy needs are met, without placing anyone at risk of financial harm.”

As part of CEA’s national consumer advocacy, CEA’s Campaign for New Mexico’s Energy has recently launched a new Community Commitment initiative focused on working with New Mexicans and local businesses to build and sustain an energy future that balances environmental aspirations with economic realities. The initiative highlights how the responsible development of all of New Mexico’s energy resources, from solar to wind to natural gas, can help sustain its neighbors, restaurants and brewerieslocal businessestribal nations and families who depend on a healthy economy to put food on the table.

To learn more, please visit https://consumerenergyalliance.org/campaign-for-americas-energy/new-mexico.

###

About Consumer Energy Alliance
Consumer Energy Alliance (CEA) is the leading voice for sensible energy and environmental policies for consumers, bringing together families, farmers, small businesses, distributors, producers, and manufacturers to support America’s environmentally sustainable energy future. With more than 550,000 members nationwide, we are committed to leading the nation’s dialogue around energy, its critical role in the economy, and how it supports the vital supply chains for the families and businesses that depend on them. CEA works daily to encourage communities across the nation to seek sensible, realistic, and environmentally responsible solutions to meet our nation’s energy needs.

Contact:
Bryson Hull
(202) 657-2855
bhull@consumerenergyalliance.org

 

CEA’s Top 5 Favorite Energy Stories This Week – July 23

U.S. lawmakers continue to work towards a compromise in a bi-partisan infrastructure package. Negotiators say they are hoping to finish the package by Monday.

The week kicked off with U.S. crude oil prices falling sharply, as concerns over global economic recovery were raised due to the increased spread of the coronavirus Delta variant. However they rose more than 4% on Wednesday and edged higher on Friday on expectations that supply will remain tight throughout the year.

U.S. crude stockpiles rose for the first time since May this week as imports increased to their highest in a year.

As the Biden Administration continues to make strides in advancing offshore wind production, U.S. workers, manufactures and consumers can expect lower energy costs and thousands of job opportunities.

Catch up on more of this week’s energy news below!

5Floating offshore wind farms could help California’s power supply

Did you know that Northern California has some of the strongest offshore winds across the U.S.? PBS explains why that region of the state would benefit from floating offshore wind farms to mitigate for how quickly its continental shelf drops off.

4Crawling robots help with oil and gas inspections

With better data and sensors, robots are improving how they can help to inspect pipeline assets and help to mitigate safety risk for human workers. RigZone details how digitization benefits the oil and gas industry and where robots fit into this new trend.

3Oil shippers using technology

Oil shippers are using technology to help combat the transfer of oil by countries under sanctions by monitoring ships and analyzing documentations. Reuters reports on how oil shipping companies have started utilizing technology to prevent accidental breaches of sanctions, given the tough restrictions.

2


Hydrogen battery sponges can store solar

Researchers are examining how to harness the sun’s energy by storing it and using it to produce green hydrogen. IEEE describes how solar farms are slated to use “hydrogen batteries” to store energy from solar panels, deliver power to the grid during the evening or supply green hydrogen to other industries.

1


A breakthrough in long-duration batteries

A new battery uses iron, water and air to store enormous amounts of electricity and then discharge power for days. The Wall Street Journal uncovers how the iron-air batteries may be capable of affordable, long-duration power storage by 2025.

Building Better Opportunities for Future Generations in Rural Communities

rural energy

The town of Baker, Montana, located near the border in the eastern part of the state, is home to just over 1800 people. It was founded in the early 1900s to support the transcontinental Milwaukee Railroad, and eventually attracted homesteaders looking to plant and raise cows -laying the foundation for its agrarian heritage. In 1912, oil and gas reserves were discovered in the area and the town grew. Since then, the agriculture and energy industries have been mainstays of the area—each keeping the town afloat during downturns in one industry or the other.

Due to the geology of this area of Montana, a complex pipeline infrastructure has evolved to carry energy to consumers all over the country. In fact, in Montana, there are about 15,618 miles of oil and gas pipeline in the ground—providing reliable tax revenue for local and county governments. In 2006 and 2007, over $600,000 funneled down to the city from oil and gas each year. These pipelines are not just transporting oil—they are helping to cut carbon. The Denbury Cedar Creek Anticline complex is carrying CO2 from nearby oilfields used in other operations that enable carbon to be permanently stored beneath the ground instead of injected into our atmosphere, drastically cutting greenhouse emissions.

With each new project comes an influx of service workers to the rural town—buying goods from Baker’s small businesses and dining in restaurants on Main Street. It takes 500 workers to build 100 miles of pipeline, according to the Association of Oil Pipelines (AOPL). Even after the construction is finished, many of these workers stick around for years after the pipeline is in service.

In fact, second to the local hospital, the main employers in town are oil and gas companies and companies servicing the energy operations. The infrastructure built by energy companies to support their workforce also typically remains permanent features in the town—providing backup water supply during seasons of drought, or additional recreational housing like the RV park on the nearby lake, originally constructed to house pipeline workers.

The presence of industries, like energy, has helped bring rural economic development and other benefits that small towns don’t often get to experience.

Mayor, Steve Zachmann, talked firsthand about how the energy industry, specifically oil and gas, has supported the small town for decades—attracting high-quality teachers to a tiny corner of Montana, enabling young families to return home to raise their kids, and supplying the city with much-needed water infrastructure during hard times—especially this year’s historic drought season.

Steve Zachmann, the newly appointed Mayor of Baker and second-generation eastern-Montanan, grew up in the carpentry and construction business in the town. He spoke of times when the homebuilding market was down, the oil and gas development in the area provided an opportunity for his family business to stay in operations, pouring concrete and building structures for the industry. While the ranch lifestyle and ag industry continue as a critical piece of the local economy and southeast Montana’s heritage, many ranch families are able to sustain their family operations during downtimes thanks to oil and gas production on their property. The town is also home to a 150 MW wind farm and there will soon be an 1100-acre solar farm nearby in Fallon County.

The superintendent of Baker High School Aaron Skogen also spoke about how the complex pipeline infrastructure and oil and gas industry have enabled the school district to thrive. Aaron is a young father raising his three young children with his wife. He shared how the energy industry has enabled Baker Public Schools to continue as a Class B school, have state-of-the-art facilities like a phenomenal football stadium, one of the best in the state, and importantly, attract high-quality teachers to an otherwise forgotten corner of the state. In fact, with revenues from oil and gas development, the school is able to augment other sources of revenue to support teachers and provide high-quality resources to its students, such as AP courses and technical training, better preparing their students for productive careers ahead.

Importantly, young families like Aaron’s are staying in rural towns like Baker, raising their young children and really enjoying it. Whether it’s swimming in the Community Recreation Center pool on campus or boating and fishing in the lake, young families are able to have an enjoyable quality of life—an increasingly rare story in today’s rural America—thanks to a robust energy industry.

Aaron Skogen – Students Win As Their Small Town Comes With Offers Similar to a Big Town

Steve Zachmann – Stabilizing a Community Through Energy

Pittsburgh International Airport’s Solar and Natural Gas Microgrid is the First of its Kind

Pittsburgh Pennsylvania

Today, Pittsburgh International Airport becomes the first airport in the world to be completely powered by a solar energy & natural gas microgrid, further evidence of “better together” and that the “Pittsburgh Model” shows how to lead in building the economy of the future.

Since 2014, CEA has been proud to support Pittsburgh’s plan to run its airport off a microgrid that uses both solar and natural gas produced right on the airport grounds.

It’s a great example of things that go better together, as CEA Mid-Atlantic Director Mike Butler eloquently argued in 2019. Our friends at the Builders Guild of Western Pennsylvania more recently called that kind of solution “The Pittsburgh Model”. We couldn’t agree more with that smart approach, in which decisions about consumers and the environment are made in balance and collaboration. Everyone wins when we recognize that somethings are better together.

Read more – Pennsylvania News Today